A wedge between us?
18th March 2015 by Danny Clifford
It always seems slightly pointless to go too deeply into specific measures announced by a Chancellor in a Budget statement that immediately precedes a General Election. George Osborne can wax lyrical about what he intends to do, but of course the electorate may not give him the opportunity.
There were though some interesting measures announced that are likely to be followed through regardless of who is in power, and “abolishing the end of year tax return” is one measure that certainly catches the eye – but then I imagine it was supposed to.
It will be interesting to see exactly how this works through. On the face of it I foresee little change in that those who rely on Agents (such as Ensors) to complete their tax filing obligations are likely to continue to do so under the new regime given that the onus remains with the taxpayer to ensure all relevant information is disclosed to HMRC.
Those with very straightforward affairs should be able to log on and check that all of the entries that previously they would have made on a return have been correctly picked up by HMRC from their employer, bank and pension provider etc. Effectively it should remove the need to actually input the figures – assuming HMRC’s figures are correct.
On the face of it I am in favour of the proposal, but long and bitter experience of previous HMRC “wedges” leaves me nervous that I am only glimpsing the thin end of something bigger.
Looking at the statistics, HMRC are expecting many more people to operate “digital accounts” than currently file self assessment returns. Many basic rate taxpayers rely on HMRC to give them a code each year and to deal with tax collection with no particular input needed from the individual. Will those people now have to log on and check their digital account?
If there is a thick end to this wedge, could it be that if you do not click on an “accept” button (or else enter alternative information) by a certain date there will be penalties? By forcing everyone to accept/reject the information you are, of course, forcing an explicit declaration that everything has been reported. So if the information is incomplete and that is not spotted, again will there be penalties? Of course tax advisors have always been alert to this – but will all of the individuals who are new to the game be so aware? My sceptical side tells me HMRC are not going to easily let go of a penalty regime and source of revenue that they have spent the last decade building up.
My favourite HMRC statement on this topic is that people will be able to pay their tax “when it is most convenient for them to do so”. Before anyone gets too excited, I strongly sense this means earlier than now – not later. Which leads me to another concern. If all of your information is online by 6th April, and you can check and confirm that by, say, 30th April – why not pay any tax due then - some 9 months earlier than you have to pay it now? I am sure that the thought of collecting tax earlier has not occurred to HMRC at all …
To view the key points of the Budget please click here.
« Back to blog